Who would the other Trek Captains choose?

[edmcgon 0]

When I was watching the "Enterprise" episode "Carpenter Street", I had a thought: When Archer was given the choice of taking only one crew member with him on the mission (for which he did not know what dangers he might face), he chose T'pol. Faced with a similar choice, who from their crews would the other Trek captains have chosen?

 

My opinion:

 

TOS: Kirk would have chosen Spock. Kind of a no-brainer.

TNG: I think Picard would have chosen Data. Picard just seemed to have great loyalty and respect for Data.

DS9: IMO, Sisco would pick Dax (either host).

VOY: Janeway would pick Tuvok.

 

I made the DS9 and VOY choices based on the fact that both captains had known those crewmembers longer than their other crewmembers, so they had built up a greater amount of trust and loyalty over time.