Did Archer make the right decision?

[SpocksBrain 0]

OK, OK, I admit it... I picked porthos too... :o

 

It was obviously best to send Archer because he knew the most about that one Xindi that hey brainwashed in a previous episode. :o

Edited March 29, 2004 by SpocksBrain

[Rick Alverado 0]

Porthos would have been able to succesfully destroy the weapon and make peace with the Xindi because as we all know he is the most influential character on Enterprise.

[Mike 5]

Under different circumstances I would have said that Archer should have stayed on Enterprise and someone else taken this mission..Tucker or Mayweather..Or both..But this wasn't a normal mission..Captain Archer had to do this himself..Daniels made it quite clear that it was Archer who had to go and talk to the Xindi..

[Admiral Kirk 1]

I honestly thought Mayweather should have mainl because he's the best pilot on the ship. The Captain is too important to the mission to sacrifice himself.

[Jeanway 0]

Porthos would have been able to succesfully destroy the weapon and make peace with the Xindi because as we all know he is the most influential character on Enterprise.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I think you may be on to something here

[A l t e r E g o 9]

Imo the Jackpot goes to touchthesky and Spacetigger, Archer had to go.

 

If anyone else had gone the enemy would have declared a victory in that particular temporal incursion. Daniels made sure Archer understood that at the crossroads they were standing on, the point of TCW was to make Archer choose the path divergent from the way he was supposed to choose. Perhaps the better question is 'should Daniels have interfered?' My answer would be yes; it is after all a war.

[J Archer 0]

I'll agree with the majority and vote Me.