Cyrano Jones vs. "Harry" Mudd

[DrWho42 13]

Which of these two characters did you like more?

They were both astral traders... Starfleet probably didn't take kindly to Cyrano Jone's tribbles... Neither to Mudd (In Your Eye... )...

 

What's your opinion?

Click For Spoiler

[Mr.Picard 12]

Harry Mudd's attitude towards women wasn't exactly that what I would call "nice" or "advanced", but still, he's cool because he's so annoying and he doesn't give a **** about rules or regulations (reminds me of Q ).

 

So, my vote goes to Mr. Harry Mudd. -_-

 

Oh and I loooooooove his wife (or should I say wives? -_- ) in that episode -_- -_-

[VaBeachGuy 12]

Mudd the First. I have an old Star Trek computer game from about 14 years ago that had Harry in it as a matter of fact.

[WEAREBORG4102 0]

Mudd was a wacko and funny. That means he gets my vote...

[TransporterMalfunction 1]

Harry Mudd!

[fredbroca 0]

I really liked them both. They had each a quality that was fun to watch. They both had episodes on tas or at least I rember one with cyrano jones in it. It would be hard to compare the two yes they were both traders but the comparason ends their. Mudd was a big crook and would break the law whenever he felt like it. Jones was a nice man that was just trying to make a living. So I like them both.

[Delta 0]

I voted for Harry Mudd, he was so annoying that he was funny.

[Mike 5]

I'm struggling with this.. I want to vote for Harry Mudd..What an enjoyable and funny character! But then I think of Cyrano Jones and all those wonderful Tribbles..So I had to vote for both !!

[Admiral Kirk 1]

I voted for Harry. I wish there were more TOS episodes featuring him.

[Data 0]

Cyrano Jones, Harry Mudd was just annoying.

[TC1 0]

I'd have to agree with Data, Cyrano Jones was much more of a character than Harrry Mudd. I like both, but the Trouble with Tribbles was classic!

 

"What're you tryin' to do? Ruin the market!"

[BakulaBabe 2]

Harry Mudd. He was funnier, especially when he was trying to get out of trouble. B)

[DixonHill1989 0]

I like them both the same.

[RikerChick 5]

Harry Mudd

[Gabri 0]

I liked the tribbles better than I did Cyrano, whereas Harry Mudd had such a pronounced personality. I definitely have to go with Harry.

 

[Airies 0]

I like Mr. Jones. Harry Mudd always annoyed the heck out of me. I mean Jones annoyed me too but in a more drunken sort of way.

[hangon 3]

My vote goes to Cyrano Jones i guess because i loved that episode so much :)

[DaboGirl 7]

 

Harry Mudd, of course.

 

 

[KIMIMELA 1]

I can just about put up with Q but Mudd was just plain annoying, so I voted neither. I recently watched that episode for the first time (YES! :) :) ) and hated it although some parts were funny I must admit.

[oldfan1 0]

I had to vote Harry Mudd, Harry was a rather "roguish" character whereas Cyrano Jones was boring. Beautiful women vs. cute fuzzballs, beautiful female androids vs. cute fuzzballs.

 

Harry did have one other advantage over Cyrano, the Stella android that he could tell to shut up when it nagged him of course Kirk had to ruin THAT. :)

[trekz 7]

They were both fun in different ways, so I voted both. Both actors did a great job in their roles.

[Voyager recruit 0]

I agree with Trekz, that they both had their aspects, but, Cyrano was the amiable one of the two-a more or less harmless entrepeneur, out to make a credit on the fringes of space...

[Bethlehem 7]

I went with Mudd thought it was a great role. Besides I can not place Jones

[Kor37 9]

I went with Mudd thought it was a great role. Besides I can not place Jones

Cyrano Jones was the guy from " The Trouble With Tribbles"

[Bethlehem 7]

Thanks Kor. Boy talk about having senior moments he was great still second to old Harry but really really close.

[prometheus 0]

i think that they were gay lovers with a cunning plan which failed

[Bethlehem 7]

I certainly did not see that one comeing. Nor would I have suspected it.

[Spike The Trill 0]

I put "depends on which episode" becasue, for me, Mudd was much more enjoyable in "I, Mudd".

[Stephen of Borg 2]

depends on which Mudd episode. I hated his first appearance episode, but loved his second.

[He Who Shall Not Be Named 2]

Harry Mudd was a straight-up pimp. He even dresses like one. That's why I like him. It also gives me hope for the future that a middle-aged white man can do that in the future.